Yes, but only in one direction. Renter’s insurance usually covers injury claims made against you, through its personal liability and medical payments to others coverages, when someone is hurt in your apartment and you are responsible. It does not pay for your own injuries. If you are the one who got hurt, your claim is usually against whoever caused it, such as your landlord, another tenant or a driver, and against that person’s insurance.

Key Takeaways

  • Renter’s policies typically include personal property, loss of use, personal liability and medical payments to others coverage.
  • Personal liability coverage can pay a guest’s injury claim and your legal defense if you are found responsible, up to the policy limit.
  • Medical payments to others is meant for smaller medical bills of visitors. As the name says, it is for other people, not you.
  • Your landlord’s insurance does not cover your belongings, and your renter’s policy does not cover the building.
  • If a building defect injures you or your guest, the landlord may be responsible. In New York City apartment buildings, the Multiple Dwelling Law requires owners to keep the building in good repair.

What Renter’s Insurance Covers

The New York Department of Financial Services lists four main coverages in its consumer guide to renters insurance: personal property, loss of use, personal liability and medical payments to others. DFS also points out a common misunderstanding: many renters assume the landlord’s policy covers their possessions, but a landlord does not provide insurance for a tenant’s personal property.

Coverage

What it does

Does it pay for your own injury?

Personal property

Pays to repair or replace your belongings after a covered loss such as fire, theft or a burst pipe

No

Loss of use

Pays extra living costs if damage forces you out of the apartment

No

Personal liability

Pays claims by others for injury or property damage you are legally responsible for, plus defense costs

No

Medical payments to others

Pays limited medical bills for a guest injured in your home

No

Every coverage is subject to the policy’s limits and exclusions, so the declarations page and the policy wording control. DFS recommends making sure any renters policy you buy includes liability coverage.

When a Guest Is Injured in Your Apartment

Say a friend trips on a loose rug in your living room and breaks a wrist, or your neighbor’s child is bitten by your dog during a visit. The injured person can make a claim against you, and this is where renter’s insurance does its most important work.

  1. Notify your insurer promptly. Policies require notice of an accident or claim within a set time. New York gives some protection here: under Insurance Law Section 3420(a)(5), a liability policy issued in New York must provide that late notice does not invalidate a claim unless the delay prejudiced the insurer. Do not count on that safety net, though. Report the incident right away.
  2. Medical payments coverage may pay first. For modest medical bills, this coverage may pay the guest directly, often before anyone talks about a lawsuit.
  3. Liability coverage handles larger claims. If the guest claims you were negligent, the insurer typically investigates, negotiates and, if a lawsuit is filed, provides a defense, up to the policy limit.
  4. Watch the limit. If a serious injury claim exceeds your liability limit, you could be personally exposed for the difference. Our article on what happens if someone sues you for more than your insurance covers explains how that works in New York.

Dog bites deserve a special note. Some policies limit or exclude coverage for certain animals, so check the wording if you have a pet. We cover the liability side in what happens if your dog bites someone in your home in New York.

When You Are the One Who Got Hurt

Renter’s insurance is not health insurance and does not pay for your own injuries. If you were hurt at home, the question becomes who caused the hazard.

  • A building defect: Collapsed ceilings, broken stair treads, missing handrails, defective lighting in a hallway and similar problems are usually the owner’s responsibility. Under Multiple Dwelling Law Section 78, every multiple dwelling, including its roof, must be kept in good repair, and the owner is responsible for compliance. A tenant is responsible only where the problem results from his or her own willful act or negligence, or that of a family member, household member or guest. The Multiple Dwelling Law applies in cities of 325,000 or more people, which includes New York City, to buildings occupied by three or more families living independently.
  • Another tenant: If a neighbor’s overflowing tub floods your apartment and you slip, the neighbor (and the neighbor’s renter’s liability coverage) may be responsible.
  • Outside the building: Falls on sidewalks, in stores or in parks are claims against the property owner or the party in control. A car accident is handled through auto insurance and New York’s no-fault system, not renter’s insurance.

If your guest is injured by a building defect rather than by something you did, the guest’s claim may be against the landlord as well. Our articles on whether a landlord is liable if your ceiling collapses and on stairway falls and who is liable go into more detail.

Exclusions to Check in Your Policy

Renter’s policies are written for the risks of ordinary household life. Before you rely on yours, read the exclusions section and look in particular at how it treats:

  • injuries involving cars, motorcycles and other motor vehicles,
  • business activity run from the apartment,
  • intentional acts, and
  • injuries to you and members of your own household.

DFS also notes that standard renters policies do not include flood or earthquake coverage. Short-term rentals of your apartment may also fall outside coverage, so ask your insurer before you sublet.

How Long You Have to Make an Injury Claim

Whether you are the injured guest or the injured tenant, New York generally allows three years to file a personal injury lawsuit under CPLR 214. Claims against a city agency or other public body have a much shorter notice deadline, generally 90 days under General Municipal Law Section 50-e. That matters for injuries in public housing or on public property. For more on deadlines, see the statute of limitations on personal injury claims in New York.

Getting Help With an Injury Claim

When you are hurt in a rental building, the insurance picture can involve the landlord’s liability carrier, a neighbor’s renter’s policy and sometimes your own policy, and each insurer will point to someone else. Mark E. Seitelman Law Offices has represented injured New Yorkers since 1990, and Mark Seitelman’s six years at a leading insurance defense firm give us an inside view of how carriers handle these claims. Consultations are free. Learn more about our premises liability practice.